The cheater thread

Perhaps this thread could be a clearinghouse for suspected cheating.

Just played a game where the opponent was clearly using 2 accounts. The primary account (arrrschizo) would continue playing, but the secondary account (carapuz) would join, then ally, then quit. This join/ally/quit cycle repeated about 10 times. I suspect the secondary account was joining just to feed money to the primary account.

Anyone else see similar suspicious activity?

Perhaps the developers could add some code that would prevent a player from rejoining the same game more than 5 times (or something like that).

Написао lighthauskeeper, 18.12.2010 at 00:32

Perhaps this thread could be a clearinghouse for suspected cheating.

Just played a game where the opponent was clearly using 2 accounts. The primary account (arrrschizo) would continue playing, but the secondary account (carapuz) would join, then ally, then quit. This join/ally/quit cycle repeated about 10 times. I suspect the secondary account was joining just to feed money to the primary account.

Anyone else see similar suspicious activity?

Perhaps the developers could add some code that would prevent a player from rejoining the same game more than 5 times (or something like that).

Or perhaps it would be a good idea to log IP addys of all players entering the game... duplicate IP's get auto-kicked and multiple attempts result in auto-ban? Just some thoughts.

Thanks for reporting, it's taken care of.
We'll make it so that it will only be possible to send cash after playing for at least 3 turns. And also add the duplicate IP check.

I assume any banned IPs be removed from the blacklist after a couple of days?

Написао FailureFace, 18.12.2010 at 07:28

I assume any banned IPs be removed from the blacklist after a couple of days?

IPs won't get banned, it just won't allow you to join the same game from two identical IPs.

Написао Amok, 18.12.2010 at 07:47

Написао FailureFace, 18.12.2010 at 07:28

I assume any banned IPs be removed from the blacklist after a couple of days?

IPs won't get banned, it just won't allow you to join the same game from two identical IPs.

How do roommates play together then? : (

Написао Amok, 18.12.2010 at 06:43

Thanks for reporting, it's taken care of.
We'll make it so that it will only be possible to send cash after playing for at least 3 turns. And also add the duplicate IP check.

Thanks - that's a good change.

Написао Amok, 18.12.2010 at 07:47

Написао FailureFace, 18.12.2010 at 07:28

I assume any banned IPs be removed from the blacklist after a couple of days?

IPs won't get banned, it just won't allow you to join the same game from two identical IPs.

Oh, I see...

Написао Guest14502, 18.12.2010 at 09:01

Написао Amok, 18.12.2010 at 07:47

Написао FailureFace, 18.12.2010 at 07:28

I assume any banned IPs be removed from the blacklist after a couple of days?

IPs won't get banned, it just won't allow you to join the same game from two identical IPs.

How do roommates play together then? : (

Now that's a good question. Guess we'll just have to limit transfers to minimum 3 turns play.

Well, as long as you only block Joining Games, if people on the same IP are allready in game it shouldn't be too much of an issue, and if they arn't, then not being part of paricular game won't do them any harm.

Написао FailureFace, 18.12.2010 at 11:03

Well, as long as you only block Joining Games, if people on the same IP are allready in game it shouldn't be too much of an issue, and if they arn't, then not being part of paricular game won't do them any harm.

Actually, I've found a very neat solution how to disallow joining the same game from the same PC. It's better than checking by IP, so roomies will appreciate that

Yay

There should be a "no players from same IP" option, that way you can play a game with your roommates if you want, otherwise you can check it and keep potential cheaters out.

"Actually, I've found a very neat solution how to disallow joining the same game from the same PC. It's better than checking by IP, so roomies will appreciate that "
Is this is one of those things where you can't make public how you are preventing cheating because that would tell the cheaters how to get around the problem?

"Actually, I've found a very neat solution how to disallow joining the same game from the same PC. It's better than checking by IP, so roomies will appreciate that "
Is this is one of those things where you can't make public how you are preventing cheating because that would tell the cheaters how to get around the problem?

Написао wbtanks, 23.12.2010 at 01:57

Is this is one of those things where you can't make public how you are preventing cheating because that would tell the cheaters how to get around the problem?

Exactly

Hey please do continue to allow people with the same IP address to play! I've been playing this game with my brother ever since the start of this game, really enjoying it.

Написао Azure, 25.12.2010 at 20:59

Hey please do continue to allow people with the same IP address to play! I've been playing this game with my brother ever since the start of this game, really enjoying it.

Don't worry, we don't plan to disallow that

Написао Amok, 26.12.2010 at 05:44

Написао Azure, 25.12.2010 at 20:59

Hey please do continue to allow people with the same IP address to play! I've been playing this game with my brother ever since the start of this game, really enjoying it.

Don't worry, we don't plan to disallow that

What a relief I'm in the same situation here.

How are these new players popping up getting such a high rank?
[Rank 7] LiodaGobert 03 Jan &
[Rank 7] n00less cluebie joined 04 Jan
im not saying they are cheating as i have no idea if someone can get to that rank that fast, but just wanting to know how many hours do these ppl put in to get this high in this short ammount of time.

Well if you play a lot it's not that hard to rank up exceptionally fast. Also it depends on their play styles. If they're just naturally good at these sort of conquest games, and are very, very aggressive. They'll get tons of SP per game and then get medals really fast. And some games give TONS of sp if you do really good, like a game I just finished ended up giving me like 25k SP. (dem gold medals) So you should check their other stats, how many games they've played, how many they've won, how many units they've killed, how many battles they've had. Cuz I mean they've been around for almost a month so being rank 7 is far from unreasonable. I've only been here for 6 days and I'm almost rank 6.

Hi all,

Thanks Crazy Ivan for compliments on my rank )

As Colt556 is saying, if you play a lot, you get ranks very fast (like any web games) It has nothing to do with skills or cheat.
Play a lot, pick up worldwide or asia games and you get ranks that fast with the right strategy.

Edit : Checking your stats and mine, You played 6698 weeks and I've played 4897 weeks. I joined two month later, but I'm close to you in game turns.

I've hardly been playing lately, and when i do i play I play small quick games & with these influx of new players (lambs to the slaughter) they are easy pickings (SP) I guess that's why I'm going down the leader board and others are ranking up fast.

Well longer games do tend to give more sp per turn due to the fact that one can have lots more battles/killings per turn.

As for myself, I notice the majority play Europe games, while I prefer Whole World or Eurasia myself. While still fairly new to Afterwind, I'm a veteran Risk player from Lux and ConquerClub as well as an Axis and Allies fanatic. Ah well, I guess that's 2 more players you're gonna have to ban to get 1st place, Crazy Ivan!

Lioda's just a bro. Hence his rank.

Well i ranked up pretty fast, but that was because not only did i have loads of previous experience playing with my friend, but because i was on holiday when i made this profile (i gave my other one to my little brother). we spent up to 8 hours a day playing together and i got ahead of him in a day or two (i had already got him to rank 5). my fav games are europe, when i do them right i can easily get 500 sp per game and i sometimes get 1000

Hey pantha do you actively search for threads that had no posts for 5 months?

I cheated on my left hand last night.

Ba dum tssshhh!

Ironail is a massive cheater. He farms rep by swapping rep with new players.