Broken game mechanics?

Does anyone know about this?

^this attack failed and I didn't know why so I asked the person and....

Not really, I just remarqued since around 6 months that it is possible to attack a wall of 30 units with just 1 milita and the wall will be broken for example. But no, walling units will not be killed, or just 1 but separeted.
Maybe since an update.

Написао Robsero, 07.11.2017 at 22:23

Not really, I just remarqued since around 6 months that it is possible to attack a wall of 30 units with just 1 milita and the wall will be broken for example. But no, walling units will not be killed, or just 1 but separeted.
Maybe since an update.

No I attacked a walled city but my attack failed because he used the units inside that city to attack the wall and used units outside to attack the wall so instead of my units attacking the city, they attacked everything that attacked the wall as he says.

This may has happened because you sent wall units to attack city and his units followed wall in city.From what I see this is not the case, so better report that player because he might be abusing the bypass walls bug.You should have taken ss of battle results as this one doesnt really prove anything.

And share his name so we know not to duel him or at least know he uses bugs when we duel him because thats clearly bug abusing.

Написао Nations, 08.11.2017 at 01:49

This may has happened because you sent wall units to attack city and his units followed wall in city.From what I see this is not the case, so better report that player because he might be abusing the bypass walls bug.You should have taken ss of battle results as this one doesnt really prove anything.

i didnt send the wall units, i left them and if there isnt a majority of who know about this glitch or so then ill share his name but i just wanna see if anyone else knows about this

It's the atwar mechanics that should take the responsibility.
He moved units on your wall from odessa and he sent another stack on the same side of the wall, your stack, because odessa had those units that attacked the wall, it followed them and had to face both of his stacks.
That's what I understand.

Написао Nations, 08.11.2017 at 01:49

This may has happened because you sent wall units to attack city and his units followed wall in city.From what I see this is not the case, so better report that player because he might be abusing the bypass walls bug.You should have taken ss of battle results as this one doesnt really prove anything.

Not a bypass walls bug....noob nwo that has been sorted out.

Aw's stupid follow mechanics happened.

Написао Guest, 07.11.2017 at 22:15

Does anyone know about this?

^this attack failed and I didn't know why so I asked the person and....

Написао Cold Case, 08.11.2017 at 04:42

It's the atwar mechanics that should take the responsibility.
He moved units on your wall from odessa and he sent another stack on the same side of the wall, your stack, because odessa had those units that attacked the wall, it followed them and had to face both of his stacks.
That's what I understand.

I tried to test this and couldn't get the units to attack the wall. I tried at least 20 times and every single time, the units attacked the city and not the wall. I could not find a way to get the units that attacked the wall or the walling units to participate in the moldova battle itself.
The only way I consistently managed to get more units to enter the defense of moldova was to intercept the Ukrainian stack that was attacking moldova.
This is demonstrated in this video.


>Notice how the units that attacked the wall never entered the fight, working how you expect the game to.

> However the units that I sent to intercept the attack stack into moldova followed the fight into moldova and was added into the defense.

Based on experience and my testing, the most reasonable explanation was that a stack that trystane used to attack moldova was intercepted. This stack was outside a city thus allowing it to be intercepted (so far trying to intercept an attack coming from inside a city is impossible to replicate). This could literally be a single unit stack like a random infantry that dragged all those turk units into moldova.

Trystane's screenshot is REALLY not helping figure it out, but that's my theory as to what happened. I doubt there was any foul play and that it was simply intercept mechanics giving wacky results.

Also if turk attacked the wall with the moldova units, half the time they would escape the city and ukr fought only againsts the intercept in moldova. The other half, they got tbbed and defended moldova alongside the intercept stack.

anyone else with another hypothesis is welcome to post it.

Написао Witch-Doctor, 08.11.2017 at 06:45

sorry I know the SS wasn't good but it was the best i could do considering i was very heated and pissed off... basically I sent my units from a walled Kiev to walled odessa. so no chance of a intercept... there must be some exploit or he just got the best rolls ever

Написао Guest, 08.11.2017 at 06:53

Написао Witch-Doctor, 08.11.2017 at 06:45

sorry I know the SS wasn't good but it was the best i could do considering i was very heated and pissed off... basically I sent my units from a walled Kiev to walled odessa. so no chance of a intercept... there must be some exploit or he just got the best rolls ever

Idk I typically find what I remember happened to be vastly different than what actually happened when I go back and look at my recording. It could be a random stack got intercept or godlike rolls like you said.